Skip to main content

Police shame over poll

An Indonesian Police general could not hide his anger in a recent TV interview about the Indonesian public perception ranking the police as the country's most corrupt institution, when he basically branded the findings of the Indonesian Chapter of Transparency International (TI) as rubbish. But with such rampant red tape, bribery and even extortion -- just look how police extort motorists for example -- perhaps even the general's colleagues in the force would laugh at his denial.


In the TI 2007 Global Corruption Barometer issued last week, Indonesian respondents listed the police as the most corrupt institution, followed by the courts, legislatures and political parties. The findings are not surprising, since it approached members of the public, who made their observations from their personal experience in daily life. In nearly all sectors, the police are widely perceived as corrupt and connected with money. Hearing the result must have made the national police ashamed and mad, but they embarrassed themselves further in their overreaction. The police response was as farcical as a soap opera, when they questioned the survey's credibility and purpose. On one occasion, a police spokesman reportedly announced that the result was like people's mind's were being poisoned or brainwashed. His response shows just how panicked and ashamed the police were.


Unfortunately, the police' case in defense has not really held up. Indonesian people are not stupid, and realize what is happening from their own experience. The accusation that TI was brainwashing the public is simply illogical. On the streets we can easily find police stopping motorists for traffic violations (and sometimes just with false accusation to pay for police officers to get coffee or cigarettes). Motorists just have to bribe police on the spot and then they can go. This is also an example of corruption. Police do not need to ask TI to prove its findings, but should open their eyes and hearts, and face the facts. The police should also not be overreacting like actors on television. The result may not be pleasing, but they should look to the House of Representatives' example. The legislators gave a more positive response to the findings and did not get mad like the police. The national police should take the result as constructive criticism, because their the accusations make them look arrogant. I think everyone would agree not all officers commit corruption.


People want to have a great national police force and know the police are trying to build an image of a respectable institution. The police have had some success in tackling big issues like drugs and terrorism, but if police on the streets and behind the scenes continually ask for bribes, their public image will not improve. In order to fix the system, police should conduct internal reforms, bring discipline to police officers and teach them not to ask for bribes, ever. We do not want to be in a situation where one corrupt institution chases another. Whether or not we will see the development of a strong, great and clean national police force is perhaps a dream that can only be realized by the national police themselves. The writer is a student of Atma Jaya University's faculty of education. He can be reached at http://sg.f586.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=michaelsetiawan%40hotmail.com

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

child sex workers in Bandung

A policeman, right, watches over two masseuses and their customers during a raid on suspected prostitution activities at a hotel in Changchun, in northeast China's Jilin province The Bandung authority is at loss to uncover cases of covert prostitution involving junior and senior high school students, whose number continues to rise in the West Java capital. Eli, a sex worker advocacy program mentor from the Rumah Cemara Group in Bandung, said it was hard to provide advocacy to teenagers involved in covert prostitution since most were not receptive. The number of those involved in covert prostitution is believed to be higher compared to commercial sex on the streets, she added. Eli has been providing support to more than 200 housewives and child sex workers over the past two years, around 20 of who are senior high school students between the ages of 15 and 16. "They are psychologically unstable at those ages. They are hard to handle due to their strong motivation to ea
Post a Comment
Read more

Bricklaying in Aceh

Refleksi: http://www.thejakartapost.com/detaileditorial.asp?fileid= 20070405. F07&irec= 6 Bricklaying in Aceh I was looking back the other day at a letter in the British newspaper The Times as written by Professor H. H. Turner in January 1925, who was challenging the government's statement that a good British bricklayer would lay 500 bricks per day which made him the best in the world.The professor claimed to have found one bricklayer who dealt with 2000 bricks in eight hours and another one who laid 890 bricks in just one hour -- one presumes the brickie ran out of steam after a while. It made me wonder just how many bricks were being laid in Aceh province, bearing in mind the climatic differences between gloomy old England and sun-drenched Indonesia. The heat factor alone could well in fact reduce the work rate by up to fifty percent, and then of course there are the incentive factors of salary and working conditions. An English bricklayer in 1925 would have earned about one
Post a Comment
Read more

Debate Islam in Indonesia

http://www.thejakar taglobe.com/ opinion/interloc utors-of- indonesian- islam/560447 Interlocutors of Indonesian Islam Ahmad Najib Burhani | December 08, 2012 A few months ago, the Japanese anthropologist Mitsuo Nakamura told me that studying Nahdlatul Ulama as an organization was beyond the imagination of any American scholar from the 1950s to the ’70s. But he is not the only academic to have noticed this. George McT. Kahin of Cornell University stated the same thing. Even NU-expert Martin van Bruinessen was not expecting to study NU as his primary focus when he came to Indonesia for the first time in the 1980s.   During the early decades of Indonesian independence, NU was relatively unorganized and its management was largely based on the authority of religious teachers ( kyai ). Of course there were a number of scholars who studied NU-affiliated religious schools ( pesantren ) and its kyai, but not NU as an organization.   Even though NU was one of the winners o
Post a Comment
Read more